Quick answer: Shingles cost less up front and look great on most homes. Metal costs more but lasts much longer, handles heat and heavy rain well, and holds up to wind when installed right. The best pick depends on your budget and how long you'll stay.
Cost
Shingles win on the day you pay. Metal often wins when you spread it over the years.
Lifespan
Insurance companies generally want shingles replaced every 15 years. A coated standing seam metal roof can last up to 50 years.
Heat and energy
Light-colored metal reflects a lot of sun, which can help your attic stay cooler.
Looks and HOAs
Some neighborhoods have rules. Check yours before you fall in love with a color.
- Architectural shingle
- Standing seam metal
- Exposed fastener metal
FAQ
Is metal noisy?
Over a solid deck and underlayment, it's usually no louder than shingles inside.
Which is better for hurricanes?
Both can be rated for high wind. Installation quality matters more than the label.
Can you quote both?
Yes, side by side.
Want someone to just look at it?
Free estimates across Flagler, Volusia, St. Johns, Clay, Putnam and Greater Orlando.
Get a free estimate Call (386) 313-6055